Unfortunately, they don’t know anything about its original source, or what case it
was connected with. It was donated by a long-deceased memorabilia
collector. Coincidentally, the archivist who helped me find it lived
on Fullerton Ave in Newburgh.

Scandal. noun. "a circumstance or action that offends propriety or established moral conceptions or disgraces those associated with it."
Unfortunately, they don’t know anything about its original source, or what case it
was connected with. It was donated by a long-deceased memorabilia
collector. Coincidentally, the archivist who helped me find it lived
on Fullerton Ave in Newburgh.